CCBC-Net Archives
Sympathy for the devil SPOILER
- Contemporary messages sorted: [ by date ] [ by subject ] [ by author ]
From: Pamela Turner <pstrst>
Date: Fri, 5 Aug 2005 19:16:42 -0700
In the context of looking at how terrible Tom Riddle/Voldemart's upbringing was, it is interesting that Harry was himself the victim of unloving
(foster) parents. Riddle's upbringing at the orphanage was arguably BETTER than Harry's. While not loving, it was not actively abusive, emotionally as Harry's clearly was. Not to take anything away from JK Rowling, but I think any child raised like Harry would probably have serious emotional problems, more like Riddle's than Harry's. In HP6 Dumbledore seems to explain Harry's unbringing away as something that prevented Harry from being "spoiled." I think that is very inadequate given the extreme treatment Harry receives from his aunt, uncle, and cousin.
Pamela S. Turner
----- Original Message ----- From: "Suzanne Fondrie" To: "Subscribers of ccbc-net" Sent: Friday, August 05, 2005 4:51 PM Subject: [ccbc-net] Sympathy for the devil SPOILER
S
P
O
I
L
E
R
S
My six-year-old waited eagerly for the HBP release and even made her own countdown calendar to help her keep track. In the meantime, she re-read all of the other books to get ready.
Her main reaction to the book wasn't centered around the startling event at the end, however. She wanted to talk about how the book made her feel sorry for characters she had never liked before: Draco, Snape, and even Voldemort himself. She pointed out how awful Voldemort's upbringing was and how little love there was for him at any point in his life. As she put it, "It's no wonder he turned out like that. No one ever loved him." She compared Harry's mother's love protection to the corrupting influence of what she called the
"not-love" that Tom Riddle experienced. She also felt new sympathy for Draco, being caught in the position he was. I totally missed Moaning Myrtle's reference to Draco crying in the bathroom, but she didn't.
There's a different, more analytical and psychological aspect to this book that I appreciate. It's not that I enjoyed it more or less than the others, but I found different things to think about in this latest story. Also, as usual, I liked being to go back to the other books and find the little hints Rowling drops about upcoming books, such as the
"oddly furtive" look (p. 866) Ron gives Harry after Ginny breaks up with Michael Corner in Order of the Phoenix.
My dad, who's nearing 80, is waiting to get his hands on our copy when we're done and keeps asking when we'll be finished. Such is the power of the Potter.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ To post to the list, send the message to...
ccbc-net at ccbc.education.wisc.edu
To leave the list, open this web page and submit your email address...
http://ccbc.education.wisc.edu/signoff.html
Received on Fri 05 Aug 2005 09:16:42 PM CDT
Date: Fri, 5 Aug 2005 19:16:42 -0700
In the context of looking at how terrible Tom Riddle/Voldemart's upbringing was, it is interesting that Harry was himself the victim of unloving
(foster) parents. Riddle's upbringing at the orphanage was arguably BETTER than Harry's. While not loving, it was not actively abusive, emotionally as Harry's clearly was. Not to take anything away from JK Rowling, but I think any child raised like Harry would probably have serious emotional problems, more like Riddle's than Harry's. In HP6 Dumbledore seems to explain Harry's unbringing away as something that prevented Harry from being "spoiled." I think that is very inadequate given the extreme treatment Harry receives from his aunt, uncle, and cousin.
Pamela S. Turner
----- Original Message ----- From: "Suzanne Fondrie" To: "Subscribers of ccbc-net" Sent: Friday, August 05, 2005 4:51 PM Subject: [ccbc-net] Sympathy for the devil SPOILER
S
P
O
I
L
E
R
S
My six-year-old waited eagerly for the HBP release and even made her own countdown calendar to help her keep track. In the meantime, she re-read all of the other books to get ready.
Her main reaction to the book wasn't centered around the startling event at the end, however. She wanted to talk about how the book made her feel sorry for characters she had never liked before: Draco, Snape, and even Voldemort himself. She pointed out how awful Voldemort's upbringing was and how little love there was for him at any point in his life. As she put it, "It's no wonder he turned out like that. No one ever loved him." She compared Harry's mother's love protection to the corrupting influence of what she called the
"not-love" that Tom Riddle experienced. She also felt new sympathy for Draco, being caught in the position he was. I totally missed Moaning Myrtle's reference to Draco crying in the bathroom, but she didn't.
There's a different, more analytical and psychological aspect to this book that I appreciate. It's not that I enjoyed it more or less than the others, but I found different things to think about in this latest story. Also, as usual, I liked being to go back to the other books and find the little hints Rowling drops about upcoming books, such as the
"oddly furtive" look (p. 866) Ron gives Harry after Ginny breaks up with Michael Corner in Order of the Phoenix.
My dad, who's nearing 80, is waiting to get his hands on our copy when we're done and keeps asking when we'll be finished. Such is the power of the Potter.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ To post to the list, send the message to...
ccbc-net at ccbc.education.wisc.edu
To leave the list, open this web page and submit your email address...
http://ccbc.education.wisc.edu/signoff.html
Received on Fri 05 Aug 2005 09:16:42 PM CDT
