From: Melody Allen <melody_allen>
Date: Tue, 31 Dec 2002 07:37:05 -0500

Diane, Ruby Holler has caused diverging assessments here in RI. All agree that Dallas and Florida are vivid, memorable and captivating characters. Some see the plot as similar to Holes, entering the tall tale or almost magical realism category as they enter the holler, especially with the build-up of the dramatically horrible orphanage. Others are bothered by the obviousness of the treasure plot and its convenient, but hollow conclusion regarding the hint about parentage. Also, some find the fact that these two adults who are sensible and have prepared for their trips go off and forget everything including common sense. Most everyone enjoyed the read as their are some great passages. I especially love the way Sarey keeps Tiller on track with the kids - their relationship as drawn isa bonus for adult readers. Melody Allen melody_allen at gw.doa.state.ri.us


One more last minute favorite that I have not seen mentioned (forgive me if I missed it in your posting): I loved Ruby Holler by Sharon Creech. Twin siblings Dallas and Florida have had a miserable life in an orphanage, until their life is changed by an older couple who show up to take them to their home in Ruby Holler. I think anyone who like Louis Sachar's Holes would like this book, as it is filled with similar twists and turns and dramatic irony.
 Peterson Marathon County Public Library, Wausau

Merri Lindgren wrote:
Received on Tue 31 Dec 2002 06:37:05 AM CST