From: Karen L. Simonetti <klsimonetti>
Date: Tue, 04 Dec 2001 10:49:58 -0600

At 08:45 AM 12/4/2001 00, Dean wrote in part:
 

Ditto! Ditto! Ditto! I really can't think of too much to add to Dean's remarks + I'm sure these few comments don't have too much input on the award rankings, but...

What struck me about ?nnie in the Kitchen- was that it works on so many levels. [Have you all figured out my theme song? The book should always work for multi-generational purposes.] Not only did I enjoy reading this title, but I was delighted to get young readers reactions (especially pleasing was that it made many children want to know more, do more....even cooking!?!?). I've also used this book in nursing homes on "family reads days" and it was sheer joy to see children, parents, grandparents and staff immediately get drawn into the book. But, as Dean points out: This was rather a banner year for many great picture books. Ginny, thanks for reminding me about the -I Had a Rooster- Again, I love its appeal for readers of all ages.

I could go on and on, but will only comment on perhaps my only disappointment (?) in the picture book arena, -Olivia Saves the Circus-. Certainly, this is another entertaining book by Ian Falconer, but not deserving of any Caldecott mention. I loved the plot, premise, problems, hysterics and all in the story. But, illustration-wise, I felt that Falconer's drawings were becoming a one-hat-trick routine. Ye Gawds! Booklist starred this title!?!? Oh well, someone always is wrong
   Seriously, however: I know the allure of a series, but those of you working with young children: What was their reaction to this sequel?


Karen Sue...now bracing herself for the onslaught of Olivia defenders...



"On a Bad Day, There's Always Lipstick"


Karen L. Simonetti phone: 312.337.7114 email: klsimonetti at earthlink.net
Received on Tue 04 Dec 2001 10:49:58 AM CST