CCBC-Net Archives

"Smack" by Melvin Burgess

From: John Peters <cf071>
Date: Tue, 2 Jun 1998 12:39:40 -0400 (EDT)

Friends, I was granted the privilege of drafting the Kirkus review for this way back in January, and can still clearly recall (no common occurrence for this highly decorated member of the Short Attention Span Corps) the growing horror I felt as the story went on--not horror as a reader or reviewer, but as an observer of what was happening to these young people. If that's not great storytelling, then what is? Even more astonishing, not only does Burgess defy the conventional wisdom that young readers have to be grabbed on page one, he doesn't really start to exploit his subject's shock value until the damage has been done (heroin isn't even mentioned until galley page 149, prostitution until 184, etc), and the most disturbing scenes are presented with the same casual offhandedness that colors the book's early events, when Tar and Gemma more or less consider themselves off on a lark. The drug doesn't overwhelm everyone like a tsunami, it overwhelms them like a poison gas, seeping through the cracks in their characters and way of life.
        Thinking about the book as a reviewer, I did wonder whether the afterword, about squatting, was really necessary. Was it in the original edition, or added for Americans? Of all the things in the book that are going to bother people, that seemed one of the minor ones. Of course, since I worked in the south Bronx for several years back in the '80's, the idea isn't particularly alien.

Find and read this book! You will/won't be sorry.

John Peters New York Public Library cf071 at freenet.buffalo.edu

***My esteemed institution asserts its right to cut me off at any level it deems fit***
Received on Tue 02 Jun 1998 11:39:40 AM CDT