From: Dorian Chong <dchong>
Date: Tue, 29 Jul 1997 14:14:23 -0700 (PDT)

I have hesitated to respond to this thread because I was having trouble with the definition of a classic. However, as the month is drawing to a close, I find that I still wish to contribute a title to this discussion. WHERE THE LILIES BLOOM by Vera and Bill Cleaver gets my nomination for classic status for the following reasons:

1. It is a personal favorite. 2. It is still in print (original copyright 1969) 3. Although it does not enjoy a high profile or widespread popularity, it does appeal strongly to some children, those willing to spend a little extra effort with a book. Currently there is a review of this book by a 13 year old who states why it is one of the best books she has read. Check it out on http://www.amazon.com under WHERE THE LILIES BLOOM. 4. It is beautifully written. The language is both regional and universal; it is poetic. 5. The characters are fully developed. Each child responds to their difficult situation individually and believably. The reader is filled with empathy, sympathy. 6. It is a compelling story of survival and coming of age, universal themes told with originality and suspense. 7. It is both funny and serious. 8. It is both realistic and like a fairytale. 9. It features strong and resourceful females, consistent with their time. 10. It has a very satisfying ending which rings true.

Although not a major award winner, it seems to be standing the test of time. Although not a popular choice, it is well loved by some children. A classic? I hope so.

Dorian Chong dchong at wahoo.sjsu.edu
Received on Tue 29 Jul 1997 04:14:23 PM CDT