From: Dorian Chong <dchong>
Date: Tue, 2 Jul 1996 20:34:28 -0700 (PDT)

I loved this book when I first read it (as an adult). It evoked memories of many childhood feelings, especially of differentness. I also agree with the comments in an earlier post that the moment when Harriet knows the diaries have been read is a heart stopping, stomach churning moment. More physical empathy (thank you Dr. Ruth for pointing that out).

I have heard criticism recently expressed, that the book is too elitist, taking place within a rich New York family and private school environment. To which I respond that it seems to illustrate beautifully the notion that certain experiences are near universal, no matter what socio?onomic class they may be set in.

I also wouldn't be surprised if lots of child readers enjoy reading about a life style different than their own, but one which they think is appealing. The story certainly shows that Harriet's life is not all milk and honey and might thus broaden the more romantic perspective of a moneyed existence for some readers.

I'd like to hear comments from others on the subject of it being elitest.

I will no doubt take my 8 year old daughter to see the movie, but I do worry if she will then ever read the book. It would be a shame, I think, if she doesn't read it.

Dorian Chong dchong at wahoo.sjsu.edu
Received on Tue 02 Jul 1996 10:34:28 PM CDT